Active Assessment: Assessing Scientific Inquiry

von: David I. Hanauer, Graham F. Hatfull, Debbie Jacobs-Sera

Springer-Verlag, 2009

ISBN: 9780387896496 , 133 Seiten

Format: PDF, OL

Kopierschutz: Wasserzeichen

Windows PC,Mac OSX geeignet für alle DRM-fähigen eReader Apple iPad, Android Tablet PC's Online-Lesen für: Windows PC,Mac OSX,Linux

Preis: 53,49 EUR

Mehr zum Inhalt

Active Assessment: Assessing Scientific Inquiry


 

Acknowledgments

7

Contents

9

to 1 Active Assessment

13

1.1 Scientists as Educators

13

1.2 The Context and Aims of This Book

13

1.3 Relevant Historical Developments in Science Education

14

1.4 Active Assessment Defined

15

1.5 The Underpinning Principles of Active Assessment

16

1.6 On the Importance of Active Engagement

18

1.7 The Design of This Book

20

to 2 Conceptualizing Scientific Inquiry

22

2.1 Introduction

22

2.2 The Diversity of Scientific Inquiry

22

2.3 The Characteristics of Authentic Scientific Inquiry

26

2.4 An Analytical Framework for the Definition of Scientific Inquiry

28

2.5 Chapter Summary

31

to 3 An Introduction to Assessment

33

3.1 Assessment and Science

33

3.2 Assessment, Evaluation, and Testing

33

3.3 Summative, Formative, and Diagnostic Assessment

34

3.4 Distinctions in Elicitation Methods

35

3.5 Developing an Assessment Program

36

3.6 Chapter Summary

39

to 4 Assessing Scientific Inquiry

40

4.1 Introduction

40

4.2 Approaches to the Assessment of Scientific Inquiry

40

4.3 Authentic Assessment

46

4.4 The Characteristics of Authentic Scientific Inquiry Assessment (ASIA)

48

4.5 Active Assessment Development

50

4.6 Chapter Summary

51

to 5 An Analytical Framework for the Development of Scientific Inquiry Assessment

53

5.1 Introduction

53

5.2 Stages of Active Assessment Development

53

5.2.1 Stage 1: Empirical Description of Scientific Inquiry

54

5.2.2 Stage 2 -- Definition of Aims

57

5.2.3 Stage 3: Tool Development

58

5.2.4 Rubric Development

59

5.2.5 Assessment Piloting

62

5.3 Chapter Summary

62

to 6 The PHIRE Program

63

6.1 Introduction

63

6.2 What Are Phages?

64

6.3 Bacteriophages Are Ubiquitous and Host Specific

66

6.4 Bacteriophages: The Dark Matter of the Biological Universe

67

6.5 Goals of the PHIRE Program

68

6.6 The Power of Discovery

68

6.7 PHIRE: A Ten-Step Program

69

6.7.1 Step 1: Phage Isolation

69

6.7.2 Step 2: Phage Purification

70

6.7.3 Step 3: Phage Amplification

70

6.7.4 Step 4: Electron Microscopy

71

6.7.5 Step 5: Nucleic Acid Extraction and Restriction Analysis

72

6.7.6 Step 6: DNA Sequencing

74

6.7.7 Step 7: Genome Annotation

75

6.7.8 Step 8: Comparison of the DNA Sequence to Known Phage Genomes

75

6.7.9 Step 9: Comparative Genomic Analysis

77

6.7.10 Step 10: Publication

80

6.8 Is That All?

80

6.9 Whats in a Name?

81

6.10 Whos Qualified for the PHIRE Program?

82

6.11 Parallel Projects: Pros and Cons

82

6.12 Mentees and Mentors: Opportunities and Responsibilities

83

6.13 Scheduling and Flexibility

84

6.14 Multiple Milestones of Success

84

6.15 Not All Failure Is Bad

85

6.16 Transitions: From Concrete Beginnings to Abstract Representation

85

6.17 Seven Attributes of the PHIRE Program

86

6.17.1 Attribute 1: Technical Simplicity with Transition to Complexity

86

6.17.2 Attribute 2: Conceptual Simplicity with Transition to Complexity

87

6.17.3 Attribute 3: Flexible Scheduling Compatibility

87

6.17.4 Attribute 4: Multiple Achievement Milestones

87

6.17.5 Attribute 5: Parallel Projects and Mentoring

87

6.17.6 Attribute 6: Authentic Publishable Research

87

6.17.7 Attribute 7: Project Ownership

87

to 7 The PHIRE Program Assessment Strategy

88

7.1 Introduction

88

7.2 Aims of Undergraduate Phage Hunting

88

7.3 Detailed Analyses of Decision-Making Reasoning and Calculation in the Bacteriophage Isolation and Identification Process

90

7.3.1 Phage Isolation -- Identification Through Infection

91

7.3.2 Phage Purification Through Selective Infection

92

7.3.3 Phage Amplification -- Measuring Bacteriophage Concentration to Determine and Produce Maximum Bacteriophage Yield

93

7.3.4 Electrophoresis

94

7.3.5 Gene Determination (Annotation)

95

7.4 An Educational Assessment Strategy for the Scientific Inquiry Process of Phage Hunting

101

7.5 Weighting and Timing

104

to 8 PHIRE Assessment Tools

106

8.1 Introduction

106

8.2 The Substantive Knowledge Test

106

8.3 The Physical Checklist

107

8.4 The Visual Literacy Test

108

8.5 The Notebook Assessment Tool

110

8.5.1 Program Beginnings and Notebook Introduction

111

8.5.2 On-Going Laboratory Notebook Usage and the Provision of Feedback

113

8.5.3 Final Assessment of Laboratory Notebooks (End of Program)

114

8.6 The Knowledge Presentation Performance Test

117

8.6.1 Conference Poster Development

118

8.6.2 Conference Poster Presentation

119

to 9 Reflections from an Active Scientist-Educator

121

9.1 Introduction

121

9.2 Two for the Price of One: Integrating the Missions

122

9.3 Some Practical Concerns

123

9.3.1 Space: The Final Frontier

123

9.3.2 Money and Time

124

9.4 Why Bother with Assessment?

124

9.5 Program Attributes Revisited

125

9.6 Summary and Conclusions

126

Index

133